Common Objections and Answers to the Natural Law
Common Objections to Natural Law 1. Does this philosophy imply that all government laws and regulations are inherently illegitimate, and if so, what would replace them? - The principles of natural law assert that any law must align with universal moral truths to be considered legitimate; thus, laws that violate individual rights or freedoms are deemed invalid. In this view, a just society would be guided by a mutual understanding of these moral principles rather than imposed regulations. 2. How do we ensure accountability and prevent abuse of power among “lawmen” if they reject all forms of established legal authority? - To prevent abuse, the accountability of "lawmen" stems from their commitment to natural law and mutual consent, ensuring that they operate transparently and are held responsible by their peers in a voluntary and cooperative framework. This creates a system of checks that aligns with Ayn Rand’s emphasis on rational self-interest and ethic...